A few days back the famous
movie 'PK' appeared on TV; and I watched most of it. I had not watched this
movie in a theater when it was released because of the negative controversy
around it. So you may find my opinion interesting.
Having watched it now, if I
have to summarize my feelings in one word, I would say I found it
"undeserving". Here is how:
The movie did not really
appear 'controversial' to me; the scenes which were publicized as being
offending to Hindus were actually funny and silly. I did not even find 'Shiva
chasing' scene insulting to Lord Shiva despite being His 'fan' (modern word for
'disciple').
While watching the initial
portions of the movie I found those as hilarious, interesting, funny, stupid
and idiotic. A lot of scenes were 'supposed to be funny' while those were
actually 'hyped'. The later part of the movie after a Guru took over, was
actually 'boring'. Bollywood has simply ran out of ideas when it comes to
making religious Gurus as villains - it is the same old story of fake Gurus in
saffron robes fooling followers, pick up anything from year 1975 to 2015.
I found 'PK' an average and
hyped movie. It should have come on screens and gone away after doing 'okay'
business. But alas, religious and social organizations made it appear like an
'apocalypse' which it was not. I am sure it gained popularity due to the
controversy around it. People like me who actually did not go to watch it
because of controversy would have been outnumbered by people who actually went
to explore it because of the hype around it. (Also because other big flicks
were not released for weeks following it.)
It appeared like a casual
movie but it had gone to be the most successful movie of all time from our
country; earning Rs 700 Crores worldwide. It is sad that while our movie
industry has produced so many really great movies, those have done average
business. But this average movie did greatest business ever.
The message for religiously
sensitive audiences and genuine social organizations is - the more you protest
against it, the more you will do disservice against your own cause; so don't be
hyper about such movies. But one interesting lesson for other movie makers is -
hire some PR agencies to inflame religious sentiments of some from the previous
set; and if they are not inflamed, make them appear so by planting stories in
the media; and soon you will see the magic - your rotten potatoes will start
selling at the price of potato chips!
- Rahul Tiwary
[Disclaimer: Views expressed are personal.]